Okay, so the other day, I was at the park with my friends, and we were getting ready to play some ball. I’d brought my old baseball glove, the one I’ve had since I was a kid. It’s a good glove, you know? Broken in just right, fits my hand like, well, a glove!
But then, Sarah shows up with a softball. It’s way bigger than a baseball, obviously. And I’m looking at my glove, and looking at the ball, and I’m thinking, “Huh, can I even use this?“

The Experiment Begins
First, I just tried to catch the softball with my baseball glove. No big throws, just easy tosses. I figured that was a good way to start.
- First Attempt: The ball kinda…sat on top of the glove. It didn’t really sink into the pocket like a baseball does.
- Second Attempt: I tried to squeeze the glove shut extra hard. The ball popped out. Oops!
- Third Attempt: I angled the glove a bit, trying to “scoop” the ball. This worked a little better, but it still felt super awkward.
I kept at it for a while, trying different things. I noticed that the webbing on my baseball glove was pretty tight. It didn’t have much give, making it hard to really grab the bigger softball.
Getting a Little More Serious
Next, we started playing a proper game. Short distances, still, but more like a real game situation. This is where things got tricky. I managed to catch a few soft throws, but anything with any speed was a problem.
I realized the shallow pocket of my baseball glove was a major issue. The softball just didn’t have enough room to settle in securely. I was dropping balls left and right! It wasn’t pretty.
The Verdict
So, after fumbling around for a good hour, I gave up. I borrowed a softball glove from someone else, and it was like night and day!

My baseball glove? Not so great for softballs.
Could use a softball glove? Yeah.
The bigger pocket, the wider webbing – it all made a huge difference. I could actually catch the ball without feeling like I was going to drop it every time.
So, lesson learned: you can try to use a baseball glove for softball, but it’s not ideal. It’s like trying to wear shoes that are two sizes too small. You might make it work for a bit, but it’s not going to be comfortable, and you’re probably going to end up tripping a lot. Best to stick with the right tool for the job, I guess!