So, I was messing around with the recruiting stuff in College Football 25 the other day, and I kept seeing these little red and green diamonds next to the players’ names. I was like, “What the heck are these things?” I mean, it’s been a while since I dove into a college football game, and honestly, I was a bit lost.
Turns out, these diamonds are all about a player’s potential. After digging around a bit, I figured it out. The red diamond basically means a player might not live up to the hype. It’s like a warning sign that they might not reach their full potential and could end up playing below what you’d expect based on their ratings.

I started to notice a pattern. I’d get all excited about recruiting some high-star guy, but then I’d see that dreaded red diamond and have second thoughts. It’s like rolling the dice – you never quite know if they’re going to be a stud or a dud. One time, I recruited this quarterback with a red diamond. He had all the right stats, looked like a future star, but man, he just never really developed. Ended up riding the bench most of his career.
- It is a tricky one.
- I have my thoughts on this one.
My Realization
Now, the green diamond is the opposite. That’s the one you want to see. It means a player has a higher ceiling than their current star rating suggests. They’re like a hidden gem, a “diamond in the rough,” as some folks are saying online. Finding a guy with a green diamond feels like hitting the jackpot. You’re getting someone who could potentially outperform their initial rating and become a real game-changer for your team.
I had much better luck with the green diamond guys. I remember snagging this wide receiver who was only a three-star recruit, but he had that green diamond. I took a chance on him, and boy, did it pay off. He ended up being one of the best players on my team, constantly making big plays and exceeding all expectations.
So yeah, those little diamonds might seem small, but they’re a big deal in College Football 25. Pay attention to them when you’re recruiting, especially the red ones, and you might just save yourself some headaches and build a killer team. Trust me. It is important.